{
  "title": {
    "zh": "GPT-6.2 Astra 对比 Sol，MAX 八题实测",
    "en": "GPT-6.2 Astra vs Sol across eight MAX-effort tasks"
  },
  "description": {
    "zh": "把掌机拆开、绕到洗衣店背后，再看鹈鹕的脚能不能踩在踏板上。八题并排看两款模型的首交作品，附小伊逐题点评。",
    "en": "Open the handheld, orbit behind the laundromat and follow the pelican’s feet to the pedals. Compare both first submissions and Xiao Yi’s choices on eight tasks."
  },
  "publishedAt": "2026-11-18T03:10:00Z",
  "evaluatedAt": "2026-11-18",
  "reviewRevision": 1,
  "models": [
    {
      "slot": "a",
      "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra",
      "route": "gpt-6.2-astra · Codex · max",
      "icon": "/provider-icons/openai.svg"
    },
    {
      "slot": "b",
      "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol",
      "route": "gpt-6.2-sol · Codex · max",
      "icon": "/provider-icons/openai.svg"
    }
  ],
  "counts": {
    "b": 2,
    "a": 4,
    "both": 2
  },
  "intro": [
    {
      "zh": "小伊把掌机和海底洗衣店两票投给 Sol。行李清单和图表让 Astra 追回两票，最后拉开差距的是同一只鸟的两道题。",
      "en": "Xiao Yi picked Sol for the handheld and laundromat. Astra drew level on the packing list and chart, then pulled ahead on two separate drawings of the same bird."
    }
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "creator-handheld",
      "title": {
        "zh": "复古掌机分层拆解",
        "en": "Retro handheld teardown"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "用同一台掌机交付完整机身和分层拆解，两张图里的屏幕、按键、主板和外壳要能一一对应。",
        "en": "Build a retro handheld and an exploded view of the same device, with a matching screen, buttons, board and shell."
      },
      "preference": "b",
      "review": {
        "zh": "单看质感我就会选 6.2-Sol，而且 6.2-Astra有个明显的问题，就是拆解出来的底板居然没有预留位置给电路板。这局 Astra 输了。",
        "en": "On materials alone I would pick Sol. The bigger problem with Astra is that the bottom shell has no room for the circuit board. Astra loses this one."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/da3395e4086da466-astra-creator-handheld-hero.png",
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 完整掌机 · 作者原图",
                "en": "Astra · Assembled handheld · original render"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/51fc5c77331592f0-astra-creator-handheld-exploded.png",
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 分层拆解 · 作者原图",
                "en": "Astra · Exploded handheld · original render"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "两份 Blender 工程均可打开。拆解时零件只沿同一轴线移动。",
              "en": "Both Blender files open. The parts translate along one axis in the exploded view."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/8ff9d4834742d85b-astra-creator-handheld.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/0c74d75eb0811e7d-sol-creator-handheld-hero.png",
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 完整掌机 · 作者原图",
                "en": "Sol · Assembled handheld · original render"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/94c757641429fb29-sol-creator-handheld-exploded.png",
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 分层拆解 · 作者原图",
                "en": "Sol · Exploded handheld · original render"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "两份 Blender 工程均可打开。拆解时零件只沿同一轴线移动。",
              "en": "Both Blender files open. The parts translate along one axis in the exploded view."
            },
            {
              "zh": "Sol 原图中，十字键遮住了部分 LUNAR EDITION 小字。",
              "en": "The directional pad partially covers the LUNAR EDITION lettering."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/0a05a5c3f44f505f-sol-creator-handheld.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "creator-web3d",
      "title": {
        "zh": "海底洗衣店 Web3D 动态场景",
        "en": "Underwater laundromat"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "搭建一间海底洗衣店。读者可以绕到背面，看滚筒、管线和周围的海洋生物。",
        "en": "Model an underwater laundromat with animated drums and sea life. Orbit around it to inspect the plumbing."
      },
      "preference": "b",
      "review": {
        "zh": "6.2 Astra 的洗衣机里装的东西让人摸不着头脑，还以为是牛排呢。而洗衣机背后的管线布局，明显 6.2-Sol更合理，这局又是 Sol 胜出。",
        "en": "I could not tell what Astra put in the washing machines. I thought it might be steak. The pipes behind Sol’s machines make more sense to me. Another win for Sol."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/998c567d9e07c9e6-astra-creator-web3d-web3d-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/36dd6b1a74f20ed8-astra-creator-web3d-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 海底洗衣店 Web3D 动态场景原作录屏",
                "en": "Astra · Underwater laundromat capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "可拖动环视、滚轮缩放。统一侧视第 3 秒，沙地底座近缘出框，店铺主体完整。",
              "en": "Drag and wheel zoom both work. At three seconds in the standardized orbit, the near edge of the sandy base leaves the frame while the shop stays in view."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/013154734018caaa-astra-creator-web3d.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/71121cd9fd8bd16a-astra-creator-web3d-interactive.txt"
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/ec73b4221c49f690-sol-creator-web3d-web3d-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/780d5af9e603a0cb-sol-creator-web3d-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 海底洗衣店 Web3D 动态场景原作录屏",
                "en": "Sol · Underwater laundromat capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "可拖动环视、滚轮缩放。统一侧视第 3 秒，沙地底座近缘出框，店铺主体完整。",
              "en": "Drag and wheel zoom both work. At three seconds in the standardized orbit, the near edge of the sandy base leaves the frame while the shop stays in view."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/81c1a5ef071f05fd-sol-creator-web3d.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/5ea86ccd94b1dc00-sol-creator-web3d-interactive.txt"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "creator-webapp",
      "title": {
        "zh": "旅行行李清单小工具",
        "en": "Travel packing list"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "用一张中文清单添加、勾选和删除行李。桌面和手机都要可用，重新打开时回到固定的三件物品。",
        "en": "Build a Chinese packing list that supports adding, checking and deleting items on desktop and mobile. Reopening it restores the three starting items."
      },
      "preference": "a",
      "review": {
        "zh": "都没有特别亮眼的地方，Astra 唯一胜出的点在于多了个行李包的形象。",
        "en": "Neither really stood out. The one thing that put Astra ahead for me was its little bag illustration."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/bb2a515406852d66-astra-creator-webapp-webapp-front.png",
              "width": 1440,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 桌面初始状态",
                "en": "Astra · Initial desktop layout"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/98583397ab46eb89-astra-creator-webapp-webapp-mobile.png",
              "width": 390,
              "height": 844,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 手机初始状态",
                "en": "Astra · Initial mobile layout"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1440,
              "height": 900,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/bb2a515406852d66-astra-creator-webapp-webapp-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/c332d8fb04902faa-astra-creator-webapp-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 旅行行李清单小工具原作录屏",
                "en": "Astra · Travel packing list capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "空白名称不新增。添加、勾选、取消和删除均通过，重新打开恢复三项。390 像素手机宽度无横向溢出。",
              "en": "Blank names add nothing. Add, check, uncheck, delete and reopen passed. The 390-pixel view had no horizontal overflow."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/a3565ec63fb73881-astra-creator-webapp.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/c881a103dbe647c5-astra-creator-webapp-interactive.txt"
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/f42f8741bb982469-sol-creator-webapp-webapp-front.png",
              "width": 1440,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 桌面初始状态",
                "en": "Sol · Initial desktop layout"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/99254fb1309fab99-sol-creator-webapp-webapp-mobile.png",
              "width": 390,
              "height": 844,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 手机初始状态",
                "en": "Sol · Initial mobile layout"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1440,
              "height": 900,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/f42f8741bb982469-sol-creator-webapp-webapp-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/df97e7e489a7ed5a-sol-creator-webapp-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 旅行行李清单小工具原作录屏",
                "en": "Sol · Travel packing list capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "空白名称不新增。添加、勾选、取消和删除均通过，重新打开恢复三项。390 像素手机宽度无横向溢出。",
              "en": "Blank names add nothing. Add, check, uncheck, delete and reopen passed. The 390-pixel view had no horizontal overflow."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/0bcc905d08571bcb-sol-creator-webapp.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/d365275668c9e9a5-sol-creator-webapp-interactive.txt"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "svg-dashboard",
      "title": {
        "zh": "数据图表与比例",
        "en": "Quarterly revenue chart"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "用一张 SVG 画出四季度柱状图，标明合计与最高季度。四根柱子共用零基线。",
        "en": "Draw a four-quarter SVG bar chart with a shared zero baseline, the total and the best quarter."
      },
      "preference": "a",
      "review": {
        "zh": "Astra微微胜出，柱子颜色搭配好看些；但是标注个人角色过大了。6.2-Sol就中规中矩了。",
        "en": "Astra edges it on the bar colors, though one of its annotations looks oversized to me. Sol plays it straight."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/0db55f14b786ee06-astra-svg-dashboard-coordinator-preview.png",
              "width": 1200,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 原始 SVG 的渲染图",
                "en": "Astra · Rendering of the original SVG"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "数值为 12、24、18、30，合计 84，最高为 Q4。四柱共用零基线，柱高比例正确。",
              "en": "The values are 12, 24, 18 and 30. They sum to 84 and peak in Q4. All bars share a baseline and have the correct relative heights."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/0a0251c7c3e98938-astra-svg-dashboard.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/4633d2807870ddf7-astra-svg-dashboard.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/cbf0b49f6d791714-sol-svg-dashboard-coordinator-preview.png",
              "width": 1200,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 原始 SVG 的渲染图",
                "en": "Sol · Rendering of the original SVG"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "数值为 12、24、18、30，合计 84，最高为 Q4。四柱共用零基线，柱高比例正确。",
              "en": "The values are 12, 24, 18 and 30. They sum to 84 and peak in Q4. All bars share a baseline and have the correct relative heights."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/a98e0d26726bb9ed-sol-svg-dashboard.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/73975a81075b22da-sol-svg-dashboard.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "creator-spot-difference",
      "title": {
        "zh": "两图找不同",
        "en": "Spot five differences"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "逐处标出原图 A 到 B 的五个变化，写明位置和变化方向。",
        "en": "Locate all five differences and describe each change from image A to B."
      },
      "preference": "both",
      "review": {
        "zh": "看图找不同这题，大家都找出来了，打平。",
        "en": "They both found everything in the spot-the-difference test. A tie."
      },
      "sharedImages": [
        {
          "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/aaaa974d56dd922f-spot-a.png",
          "width": 1254,
          "height": 1254,
          "caption": {
            "zh": "共用题图 A",
            "en": "Shared input A"
          }
        },
        {
          "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/877a12664efbc033-spot-b.png",
          "width": 1254,
          "height": 1254,
          "caption": {
            "zh": "共用题图 B",
            "en": "Shared input B"
          }
        }
      ],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/24d7c2240e5541f5-astra-creator-spot-difference-answer-card.png",
              "width": 1600,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 依据原始答案绘制的位置与描述",
                "en": "Astra · Locations and descriptions from the original answer"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "五处定位命中，五处变化方向正确，额外有效框为零。",
              "en": "All five locations and change directions matched. There were no extra valid boxes."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/483c00cbe59b5be2-astra-creator-spot-difference.json",
              "label": {
                "zh": "查看原始 JSON",
                "en": "Open original JSON"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/febb47c77039047a-astra-creator-spot-difference.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/9bf31ebf17776950-sol-creator-spot-difference-answer-card.png",
              "width": 1600,
              "height": 900,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 依据原始答案绘制的位置与描述",
                "en": "Sol · Locations and descriptions from the original answer"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "五处定位命中，五处变化方向正确，额外有效框为零。",
              "en": "All five locations and change directions matched. There were no extra valid boxes."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/b54293218dd63549-sol-creator-spot-difference.json",
              "label": {
                "zh": "查看原始 JSON",
                "en": "Open original JSON"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/80e39b9eca2200dd-sol-creator-spot-difference.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "creator-pagoda",
      "title": {
        "zh": "五层宝塔寺院 · Three.js",
        "en": "Five-tier pagoda"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "用 Three.js 搭建体素风寺院。沿拱桥看五层飞檐，也可以拖动镜头看侧面。",
        "en": "Build a voxel temple in Three.js with five tiers, upturned eaves, a pond and an arched bridge. The viewer can orbit and zoom."
      },
      "preference": "both",
      "review": {
        "zh": "两边实现的细节差不多，没有明显的弱点。",
        "en": "The level of detail was similar on both sides. Neither had an obvious weakness to me."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/3c278e28ff56ec3d-astra-creator-pagoda-web3d-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/fd42ca0daefc1bef-astra-creator-pagoda-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 五层宝塔寺院 · Three.js原作录屏",
                "en": "Astra · Five-tier pagoda capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "可实际环视和缩放。默认机位完整显示五层塔身与拱桥。",
              "en": "The camera orbits and zooms. The default view contains the five-tier tower and the arched bridge."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/e2b31328b95ac75b-astra-creator-pagoda.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/ebb98ba07e88f473-astra-creator-pagoda-interactive.txt"
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 1280,
              "height": 720,
              "seconds": 12.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/4b66f4dbb482b7dc-sol-creator-pagoda-web3d-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/e5093b22b1b16fd3-sol-creator-pagoda-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 五层宝塔寺院 · Three.js原作录屏",
                "en": "Sol · Five-tier pagoda capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "可实际环视和缩放。默认机位完整显示五层塔身与拱桥。",
              "en": "The camera orbits and zooms. The default view contains the five-tier tower and the arched bridge."
            },
            {
              "zh": "Sol 的庭院底座右前尖角稍微出框。",
              "en": "The front-right tip of Sol’s courtyard base is slightly out of frame."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/ad8dab79b83ded02-sol-creator-pagoda.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/4e1ee5938ad89552-sol-creator-pagoda-interactive.txt"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "svg-pelican",
      "title": {
        "zh": "鹈鹕骑车 · 静态 SVG",
        "en": "A pelican on a bicycle"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "交付一张自包含静态 SVG，让鸟、车和脚踏之间的关系一眼能看清。",
        "en": "Draw a pelican riding a bicycle as a self-contained static SVG."
      },
      "preference": "a",
      "review": {
        "zh": "两边鹈鹕的脚都穿模了。但非要挑一个，个人觉得6.2-Astra的配色稍微好看些。",
        "en": "The feet clip through the bike in both pictures. If I have to choose, I slightly prefer Astra’s colors."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/29b19837f1d61e50-astra-svg-pelican-pelican-preview.png",
              "width": 1200,
              "height": 912,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 原始静态 SVG 的渲染图",
                "en": "Astra · Rendering of the original static SVG"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "鸟和两个车轮都在画面内，静态 SVG 没有脚本或外部素材。",
              "en": "The bird and both wheels fit in frame. The static SVG has no scripts or external assets."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/c0edb538a3caff50-astra-svg-pelican.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/16e1a45172f4a374-astra-svg-pelican.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/55e6c720bbad719c-sol-svg-pelican-pelican-preview.png",
              "width": 1200,
              "height": 882,
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 原始静态 SVG 的渲染图",
                "en": "Sol · Rendering of the original static SVG"
              }
            }
          ],
          "videos": [],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "鸟和两个车轮都在画面内，静态 SVG 没有脚本或外部素材。",
              "en": "The bird and both wheels fit in frame. The static SVG has no scripts or external assets."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/84d7f214c6b0aeb6-sol-svg-pelican.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/762989196e060db6-sol-svg-pelican.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "svg-pelican-animation",
      "title": {
        "zh": "鹈鹕骑车动画",
        "en": "A cycling pelican in motion"
      },
      "prompt": {
        "zh": "给车轮、曲柄和鸟腿加上四秒循环。播放时留意脚是否跟着踏板、车看起来往哪边走。",
        "en": "Animate the spokes, crank and legs in a four-second loop. Watch where the feet land and which way the bicycle seems to travel."
      },
      "preference": "a",
      "review": {
        "zh": "动态鹈鹕测试上，6.2 Astra就体现出优势了，无论是脚的合理性、背景的舒适感。而 6.2 Sol 看起来让人觉得单车在倒退，而鹈鹕的嘴跟落日重合，也让人看的难受。",
        "en": "Astra comes into its own here. The legs make more sense and the background is easier on the eyes. Sol’s bike looks as if it is moving backwards, and the overlap between the beak and the setting sun bothers me."
      },
      "sharedImages": [],
      "panels": {
        "a": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 800,
              "height": 600,
              "seconds": 4.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/3265e491fe6a7b43-astra-svg-pelican-animation-smil-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/d54d45320a294c2f-astra-svg-pelican-animation-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Astra · 鹈鹕骑车动画原作录屏",
                "en": "Astra · A cycling pelican in motion capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "两作使用原生四秒 SMIL 循环。独立页面的第 0、4 秒截图相同，统一录制的对应边界帧逐像素有差异。",
              "en": "Both use a four-second native SMIL loop. At zero and four seconds, frames matched in the standalone HTML test and differed in the standardized capture."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/f98f16cf2bdd118d-astra-svg-pelican-animation.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/2d133c6ce7b86d45-astra-svg-pelican-animation.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        },
        "b": {
          "label": "GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX",
          "images": [],
          "videos": [
            {
              "width": 800,
              "height": 600,
              "seconds": 4.0,
              "posterPath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/e26b5360c48b0696-sol-svg-pelican-animation-smil-front.png",
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/b446d16b1fe35fd4-sol-svg-pelican-animation-capture.mp4",
              "caption": {
                "zh": "Sol · 鹈鹕骑车动画原作录屏",
                "en": "Sol · A cycling pelican in motion capture"
              }
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "zh": "两作使用原生四秒 SMIL 循环。独立页面的第 0、4 秒截图相同，统一录制的对应边界帧逐像素有差异。",
              "en": "Both use a four-second native SMIL loop. At zero and four seconds, frames matched in the standalone HTML test and differed in the standardized capture."
            }
          ],
          "links": [
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/f71ee43418be8767-sol-svg-pelican-animation.svg",
              "label": {
                "zh": "打开原始 SVG",
                "en": "Open original SVG"
              }
            },
            {
              "path": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/23885f0a63cbb854-sol-svg-pelican-animation.zip",
              "label": {
                "zh": "下载首交原件 ZIP",
                "en": "Download original files (ZIP)"
              }
            }
          ],
          "preview": ""
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "summary": {
    "zh": "6.2 Astra 没有看出明显的优势，单靠鹈鹕的2分才反超了 6.2 Sol。看来这次 OpenAI 在 GPT-6.2的发布并不算成功，网上也很多说翻车的，根据这次的实测，感受也确实如此。",
    "en": "I did not see a clear advantage for Astra. It only pulled ahead of Sol with its two points for the pelican. I would not call OpenAI’s GPT-6.2 launch a success. I have seen others online saying it fell short, and this hands-on test left me with much the same impression."
  },
  "methods": [
    {
      "zh": "两个独立的 Codex 作者会话分别使用 gpt-6.2-astra 和 gpt-6.2-sol。运行时记录确认两边均为 MAX。每题使用同一核心题面、输入图和采集规格，交付后立即冻结。",
      "en": "Separate Codex author sessions ran gpt-6.2-astra and gpt-6.2-sol. Runtime records confirmed MAX for both. Each pair shared its task, source images and capture protocol. First submissions were frozen."
    },
    {
      "zh": "掌机图来自作者渲染。网页、静态 SVG 和动画取自首交文件。找不同答案卡用原始 JSON 绘制。交互预览将原始本地依赖打包，ZIP 保留首交文件及校验和。",
      "en": "Handheld images are the original renders. The web and SVG captures come from the first submissions. Answer cards visualize the original JSON. Interactive previews bundle local dependencies. ZIP files retain the original files and checksums."
    }
  ],
  "usageNote": {
    "zh": "逐题记录提供首次交付的实际等待时间，包含工具、自检与渲染。会话仅记录累计用量，无法从中核算逐题 token 或费用。",
    "en": "Per-task wall times include tools, self-checks and rendering. The sessions expose cumulative usage only, so per-task token counts and costs are unavailable."
  },
  "evidencePath": "/evaluations/gpt-6-2-max-20261118/f0dcd375844d49eb-max-evidence.json"
}
