{
  "caseId": "bookshelf",
  "dateAsiaShanghai": "2026-10-27",
  "assessmentType": "AI evaluator qualitative observations plus separately linked executable checks; not independent human blind scoring",
  "status": "pass-with-scope-limits",
  "observations": {
    "status": "pass-with-scope-limits",
    "technicalEvidence": "qa/bookshelf-checks.json",
    "visualEvidence": "qa/bookshelf-contact-sheet.jpg",
    "observations": [
      "Two independent project opens confirm exact exterior dimensions,18mm boards and equal clear compartments within0.1mm tolerance",
      "Named independent panels and separate prop collections remain editable",
      "Three final1920x1080 views are legible and show the back",
      "Visual treatment is coherent but remains a simple product visualization"
    ],
    "limits": [
      "Parameters rebuild through the Python CLI; custom properties do not drive live geometry in the blend UI",
      "Only800mm/3-compartment and1000mm/4-compartment configurations were tested"
    ]
  },
  "technicalEvidence": {
    "type": "independent-automated-checks",
    "toleranceMm": 0.1,
    "variants": [
      {
        "variant": "baseline",
        "projectSha256": "8adc3c52646ab6b481f6ee4c7bb62fe672ccacd779b3e01d388ca77c46273945",
        "extentMm": [
          800.0,
          300.0,
          1200.0
        ],
        "panels": 6,
        "compartments": 3,
        "clearHeightsMm": [
          376.0,
          376.0,
          376.0
        ],
        "status": "pass"
      },
      {
        "variant": "modified",
        "projectSha256": "066afa272fd1a03727e33940bbd488dceee39ef6658ff21c262c82273073ac81",
        "extentMm": [
          1000.0,
          300.0,
          1200.0
        ],
        "panels": 7,
        "compartments": 4,
        "clearHeightsMm": [
          277.5,
          277.5,
          277.5,
          277.5
        ],
        "status": "pass"
      }
    ],
    "images": {
      "cases/bookshelf/renders/baseline_main.png": [
        1920,
        1080
      ],
      "cases/bookshelf/renders/modified_main.png": [
        1920,
        1080
      ],
      "cases/bookshelf/renders/baseline_rear.png": [
        1920,
        1080
      ]
    },
    "status": "pass",
    "limitations": [
      "Tests two parameter sets, not arbitrary sizes",
      "Parameter edits rebuild via CLI, not live drivers in the blend property panel"
    ]
  },
  "requestEvidence": [
    "/evaluations/kimi-k3-1-pro-creative/bookshelf/attempt-01.json"
  ],
  "originalInputSha256": "e70b753db31dae2f8f83a0a1f1f70fa116f19b051f21e3a6b148879fd5f1ea4f",
  "sourcePromptSha256": "86151fda84cd34fb1612185d4bf3edc051e49c38fd163d190b9acf2ae186f079",
  "billing": {
    "basis": "Kimi Coding Plan subscription quota",
    "actualMonetaryCost": null
  },
  "reviewLimits": "AI qualitative observations plus executable checks; not independent human blind scoring or an exhaustive subjective listening study."
}