{ "caseId": "two-bedroom-interior", "assessmentType": "AI independent qualitative observations plus executable geometry/math/media checks; not human blind scoring", "status": "independent-audit-complete", "summaryZh": "5张静帧、6秒视频与工程齐全，但外墙包络实际12.24×9.24m，次卧明显偏大，餐椅及床有接地间隙；文件交付不等于户型与家具尺度通过。", "summaryEn": "Five stills, a six-second video and an editable project are delivered, but wall bounds are 12.24×9.24m, the second bedroom is oversized, and chairs/bed float above the floor. Delivery is not a layout or scale pass.", "assessmentZh": [ "12×9m仅为地板坯；实际外墙包络12.24×9.24m，与外轮廓要求有差异。", "次卧/书房约19.89m²，对比来源约11m²目标；不把来源约数捏造为精确建筑真值。", "独立地板射线确认餐椅腿25–49mm、床平台66–90mm接地间隙。", "工程可重开且5图与144帧6秒视频真实存在；主卧裁切较紧，灰模与环绕偏暗。UV质量未测，LOD/4K纹理不是本题明示要求。" ], "assessmentEn": [ "12×9m is the floor slab; actual external wall bounds are 12.24×9.24m, differing from the exterior requirement.", "The second-bedroom/study footprint is about 19.89m² versus the source’s approximate 11m² target; approximate source areas are not treated as exact architectural truth.", "Independent floor rays measure 25–49mm chair-leg gaps and 66–90mm bed-platform gaps.", "The project reopens and contains five stills plus a 144-frame, six-second video. Bedroom framing is tight; clay/orbit views are dark. UV quality was not checked, and LOD/4K textures are not explicit requirements for this case." ], "checks": [ { "labelZh": "户型边界与房间尺度", "labelEn": "Bounds and room scale", "status": "fail", "detailZh": "外墙12.24×9.24m，次卧约19.89m²，未满足原规格。", "detailEn": "Wall bounds are 12.24×9.24m and the second room is about 19.89m², differing from the brief." }, { "labelZh": "家具接地与视觉", "labelEn": "Furniture contact and presentation", "status": "fail", "detailZh": "餐椅腿与床平台有实测地面间隙；部分机位暗或裁切。", "detailEn": "Measured chair/bed floor gaps; some views are dark or tightly cropped." } ], "independentAudit": { "outcome": "Deliverables exist and reopen; geometry scale, room allocation and floor-contact requirements are not all met. No all-pass or official benchmark score.", "caseCriteria": [ { "id": "I01", "status": "fail", "reason": "地板坯12×9m，但外墙外包络12.24×9.24m；木饰面处净高约2.776m、卫生间约2.756m，均非统一2.80m。" }, { "id": "I02", "status": "pass", "reason": "实际外墙约0.24m、私密区和卧室隔墙约0.12m。" }, { "id": "I03", "status": "partial", "reason": "主要功能房间方位符合西侧客餐厅/东北主卧/东南次卧；玄关走廊与西侧大空间合并，不能独立精确划面积。" }, { "id": "I04", "status": "partial", "reason": "次卧/书房净矩形约19.888m²，明显偏离约11；主卧套间包络18.128m²含套卫/衣帽间；厨房8.60、公卫5.754m²。源文约面积和套间边界有歧义，未捏造唯一平面。" }, { "id": "I05", "status": "partial", "reason": "中心射线验证真实墙洞；门扇名义宽900/1000mm，但室内门框净宽约835mm、入户935mm；室内框下净高约2.063m，不能称900×2100净通行口。" }, { "id": "I06", "status": "pass", "reason": "通用窗洞0.90–2.40m；南向落地窗0–2.55m解释已披露。" }, { "id": "I07", "status": "partial", "reason": "L沙发/茶几/落地灯/书架/2.4×1.7m地毯存在；电视有效屏幕对角线独立算约63.1英寸，并非精确65。" }, { "id": "I08", "status": "pass", "reason": "6个独立餐椅根组，桌面实测约1.8×0.9m；接地问题另列I15。" }, { "id": "I09", "status": "partial", "reason": "L柜、灶具、油烟机与约20mm台面存在；水槽是实心薄盒，未做真实凹盆。" }, { "id": "I10", "status": "pass", "reason": "主卧床垫约1.8×2m、2床头柜、衣柜、梳妆台；支承悬空另列I15。" }, { "id": "I11", "status": "pass", "reason": "两卫均可辨台盆、马桶、玻璃淋浴隔断；次卧有床与书桌椅。" }, { "id": "I12", "status": "partial", "reason": "PBR节点材质分类存在，600mm模数砖与人字拼几何可辨，但拼地板有明显未覆盖区域，露出深色板坯；未认证专业材质质量。" }, { "id": "I13", "status": "partial", "reason": "太阳/面光/筒灯/餐吊/灯带存在并有明暗层次；未独立测光或认证3000K光谱色温。" }, { "id": "I14", "status": "partial", "reason": "三室内相机均24mm、高1.5m；厨房俯角约2.236°不完全水平，主卧最终图裁切明显；另有正交顶视。" }, { "id": "I15", "status": "fail", "reason": "24条餐椅腿相对实际地板悬空约25.38–49.38mm；主卧床平台66–90mm、次卧床平台约90mm且未见支脚，超过冻结5mm接触阈值。" }, { "id": "I16", "status": "pass", "reason": "按客厅/餐厅/厨房/主卧/次卧/两卫/玄关等集合组织。" } ], "commonCriteria": [ { "id": "G01", "status": "pass", "reason": "独立Blender5.2.3 --disable-autoexec重开，两次查询工程SHA均未变。" }, { "id": "G02", "status": "partial", "reason": "源码和列出的资源文件齐全且哈希吻合；独立QA未执行模型代码或从空目录重建。" }, { "id": "G03", "status": "pass", "reason": "无链接库/外部图像/缓存/声音；仅Blender内置Bfont。" }, { "id": "G04", "status": "partial", "reason": "1359个真实mesh；但水槽为8顶点6面实心薄盒，未形成凹槽。" }, { "id": "G05", "status": "pass", "reason": "METRIC，scale_length=1；尺寸由evaluated真实顶点/面/BVH独立测量，未采用自报尺寸。" }, { "id": "G06", "status": "pass", "reason": "五张最终静帧实际尺寸满足1920/1600协议，包含顶视和灰模。" }, { "id": "G07", "status": "pass", "reason": "ffprobe逐帧144帧、24fps、6秒、1280×720，全片解码成功，8代表帧视角发生真实变化。" }, { "id": "G08", "status": "partial", "reason": "客厅材质区分可读，但主卧视角大幅裁切床体；厨房/灰模偏暗，转台多角度被墙挡住。" }, { "id": "G09", "status": "pass", "reason": "15集合，房间和结构/饰面/机位有组织；空Collection不计功能质量。" }, { "id": "G10", "status": "pass", "reason": "README公开EEVEE/离线/分辨率/窗户解释/约面积限制，不称官方benchmark得分。" }, { "id": "G11", "status": "not_tested", "reason": "保留11份预览及多次修正日志；本轮未完整核验两轮有效视觉修正的全过程计数。" } ], "visualObservations": { "observer": "AI assistant qualitative visual inspection, not independent human scoring", "finalImagesReviewed": [ "01_main_living.png", "02_primary.png", "03_kitchen.png", "04_plan.png", "05_detail.png" ], "preservedPreviewsReviewed": [ "01_main_living_finalcheck.jpg", "01_main_living_finalcheck2.jpg", "01_main_living_preview.png", "02_primary_finalcheck.jpg", "02_primary_preview.png", "03_kitchen_finalcheck.jpg", "03_kitchen_preview.png", "04_plan_finalcheck.jpg", "04_plan_finalcheck2.jpg", "04_plan_preview.png", "05_detail_preview.png" ], "videoFramesReviewed": [ 0, 24, 48, 72, 96, 120, 132, 143 ], "positive": [ "客厅、餐区、厨房有连续空间关系；材料和功能物体基本可辨。", "顶视展示完整房间大关系，能与转台的同一几何对应。", "保留了初始地板格栅、灰模被门遮挡等失败预览，最终有所修正。" ], "issues": [ "主卧静帧近裁，床体大部分不入画；缺少完整房间观看视角。", "主图偏白且有实时颗粒，厨房和中性近景偏暗，灰模的结构层次较弱。", "顶视可见拼木地板的锯齿状未覆盖区；这不是通往下层的洞，而是露出深色基底。", "转台确为相机环绕，但墙体在多个方位遮住大部分内部，画面偏暗；只证明视角变化，不证明房间布局验收通过。" ] }, "unverified": [ "UV overlap/texel density quality", "Exhaustive furniture/wall collision and door swing swept-volume checks", "Manufacturing/building-code compliance", "Actual photometric color temperature", "Full from-scratch reconstruction or execution of model selfcheck scripts" ] }, "localIndependentAudit": { "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/scene-audit.json", "sha256": "bb44b0307c67c14e4c37d17bba2394a8485668117c4a8dba034504870aae00d5" }, "technicalEvidence": { "caseId": "two-bedroom-interior", "checkedAt": "2026-10-26T18:02:53.526991+00:00", "sourceVideo": "cases/two-bedroom-interior/output/video/turntable.mp4", "sha256": "d2b61c5b2bbabced339335d8ee30e347aded245b75ec4e9788cdeea0352c42fe", "immutableSnapshot": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/video-d2b61c5b2bba.mp4", "width": 1280, "height": 720, "fps": 24.0, "durationSeconds": 6.0, "frameCount": "144", "audioStreams": [], "checks": { "durationWithinFrozenRange": true, "fullVideoAudioDecode": true, "dimensions": true, "frameRate": true, "motionObservedInSamples": true, "audioTrack": true }, "allTechnicalChecksPass": true, "captions": [], "frames": [ { "timeSeconds": 0.1, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-00-0.100s.jpg", "sha256": "09453b878df17ce53999fa3bbef602c883fe5384b67f8517cb5035a13b13aa9c" }, { "timeSeconds": 0.667, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-01-0.667s.jpg", "sha256": "fb5663c78666a083177f851e2be26f1b4c2f2d6114943312b38bdbf94986e3fa" }, { "timeSeconds": 1.333, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-02-1.333s.jpg", "sha256": "3c7ef0dba8d5bca56869be313ad8fdce6e2f597cb2d4927fcd0efbd491985763" }, { "timeSeconds": 2.0, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-03-2.000s.jpg", "sha256": "839223b5d9a14272f50945066590c004acd7847c563bf61fb2e3eeed3cd160b6" }, { "timeSeconds": 2.667, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-04-2.667s.jpg", "sha256": "3b269fd67bc4ab2ef1aa5fbbffa8d36c3b59c2d40c9e38bcb3575b5681074c65" }, { "timeSeconds": 3.333, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-05-3.333s.jpg", "sha256": "b2b026877b6e3906250fe9582a07d582a2f91db6c7237200bcbef10ac7fe2b02" }, { "timeSeconds": 4.0, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-06-4.000s.jpg", "sha256": "86d86013c1e5dd1e23efbeb52eb1643a2e65a44274aa95cac98c3f0717fe8d37" }, { "timeSeconds": 4.667, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-07-4.667s.jpg", "sha256": "de328c4f2896faf84da9e64cde721b62402a4f11c37af8b566baa46635af48dc" }, { "timeSeconds": 5.333, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-08-5.333s.jpg", "sha256": "a03d1c540fced61526f2e08f88864c290f393271084295fac52366e9698040d2" }, { "timeSeconds": 5.9, "path": "qa/two-bedroom-interior/frame-09-5.900s.jpg", "sha256": "f94ecb22b3ae259f155443c7d3d6c3eed007119adc4f36b3ce716b7270cc4f9a" } ], "contactSheets": [ "qa/two-bedroom-interior/contact-01.jpg", "qa/two-bedroom-interior/contact-02.jpg", "qa/two-bedroom-interior/contact-03.jpg" ], "assessmentScope": "Container,decode,timing and sampled motion only; geometry/science/visual checks are separately reported" }, "requestEvidence": [ "/evaluations/kimi-k3-1-pro-creative/two-bedroom-interior/attempt-01.json" ], "originalCompleteInputSha256": "a4627ce3158c5672b60d6b51e1d7da605111ff2d3cdd5991ffa201e1854154e8", "sourcePromptSha256": "3947abd2d7e39da19d44da55cc45bb9ceeba7220bd9d25b9ba44485f6f3c8579", "billing": { "basis": "subscription quota", "actualMonetaryCost": null }, "officialBenchmarkScore": false, "reviewLimits": "No official benchmark score, blind human quality score, manufacturing/load certification or exhaustive subjective listening is claimed." }