GPT-6.2 Astra vs Sol across eight MAX-effort tasks

Open the handheld, orbit behind the laundromat and follow the pelican’s feet to the pedals. Compare both first submissions and Xiao Yi’s choices on eight tasks.

Updated: 2026-11-18

AI打工人小伊 · 2026-11-18 · Eight tasks, original work and personal commentary

GPT-6.2 Astra
GPT-6.2 Astra

gpt-6.2-astra · Codex · max

GPT-6.2 Sol
GPT-6.2 Sol

gpt-6.2-sol · Codex · max

Xiao Yi picked Sol for the handheld and laundromat. Astra drew level on the packing list and chart, then pulled ahead on two separate drawings of the same bird.

4GPT-6.2 Astra
2GPT-6.2 Sol
2Ties

One personal choice per task across eight tasks.

Retro handheld teardown

Build a retro handheld and an exploded view of the same device, with a matching screen, buttons, board and shell.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Astra · Assembled handheld · original render
Astra · Assembled handheld · original render
Astra · Exploded handheld · original render
Astra · Exploded handheld · original render
Checked facts
  • Both Blender files open. The parts translate along one axis in the exploded view.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Sol · Assembled handheld · original render
Sol · Assembled handheld · original render
Sol · Exploded handheld · original render
Sol · Exploded handheld · original render
Checked facts
  • Both Blender files open. The parts translate along one axis in the exploded view.
  • The directional pad partially covers the LUNAR EDITION lettering.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Sol

On materials alone I would pick Sol. The bigger problem with Astra is that the bottom shell has no room for the circuit board. Astra loses this one.

Underwater laundromat

Model an underwater laundromat with animated drums and sea life. Orbit around it to inspect the plumbing.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Astra · Underwater laundromat capture
Checked facts
  • Drag and wheel zoom both work. At three seconds in the standardized orbit, the near edge of the sandy base leaves the frame while the shop stays in view.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Sol · Underwater laundromat capture
Checked facts
  • Drag and wheel zoom both work. At three seconds in the standardized orbit, the near edge of the sandy base leaves the frame while the shop stays in view.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Sol

I could not tell what Astra put in the washing machines. I thought it might be steak. The pipes behind Sol’s machines make more sense to me. Another win for Sol.

Travel packing list

Build a Chinese packing list that supports adding, checking and deleting items on desktop and mobile. Reopening it restores the three starting items.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Astra · Travel packing list capture
Astra · Initial desktop layout
Astra · Initial desktop layout
Astra · Initial mobile layout
Astra · Initial mobile layout
Checked facts
  • Blank names add nothing. Add, check, uncheck, delete and reopen passed. The 390-pixel view had no horizontal overflow.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Sol · Travel packing list capture
Sol · Initial desktop layout
Sol · Initial desktop layout
Sol · Initial mobile layout
Sol · Initial mobile layout
Checked facts
  • Blank names add nothing. Add, check, uncheck, delete and reopen passed. The 390-pixel view had no horizontal overflow.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Astra

Neither really stood out. The one thing that put Astra ahead for me was its little bag illustration.

Quarterly revenue chart

Draw a four-quarter SVG bar chart with a shared zero baseline, the total and the best quarter.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Astra · Rendering of the original SVG
Astra · Rendering of the original SVG
Checked facts
  • The values are 12, 24, 18 and 30. They sum to 84 and peak in Q4. All bars share a baseline and have the correct relative heights.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Sol · Rendering of the original SVG
Sol · Rendering of the original SVG
Checked facts
  • The values are 12, 24, 18 and 30. They sum to 84 and peak in Q4. All bars share a baseline and have the correct relative heights.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Astra

Astra edges it on the bar colors, though one of its annotations looks oversized to me. Sol plays it straight.

Spot five differences

Locate all five differences and describe each change from image A to B.

Shared input A
Shared input A
Shared input B
Shared input B

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Astra · Locations and descriptions from the original answer
Astra · Locations and descriptions from the original answer
Checked facts
  • All five locations and change directions matched. There were no extra valid boxes.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Sol · Locations and descriptions from the original answer
Sol · Locations and descriptions from the original answer
Checked facts
  • All five locations and change directions matched. There were no extra valid boxes.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · Tie

They both found everything in the spot-the-difference test. A tie.

Five-tier pagoda

Build a voxel temple in Three.js with five tiers, upturned eaves, a pond and an arched bridge. The viewer can orbit and zoom.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Astra · Five-tier pagoda capture
Checked facts
  • The camera orbits and zooms. The default view contains the five-tier tower and the arched bridge.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Sol · Five-tier pagoda capture
Checked facts
  • The camera orbits and zooms. The default view contains the five-tier tower and the arched bridge.
  • The front-right tip of Sol’s courtyard base is slightly out of frame.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · Tie

The level of detail was similar on both sides. Neither had an obvious weakness to me.

A pelican on a bicycle

Draw a pelican riding a bicycle as a self-contained static SVG.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Astra · Rendering of the original static SVG
Astra · Rendering of the original static SVG
Checked facts
  • The bird and both wheels fit in frame. The static SVG has no scripts or external assets.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Sol · Rendering of the original static SVG
Sol · Rendering of the original static SVG
Checked facts
  • The bird and both wheels fit in frame. The static SVG has no scripts or external assets.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Astra

The feet clip through the bike in both pictures. If I have to choose, I slightly prefer Astra’s colors.

A cycling pelican in motion

Animate the spokes, crank and legs in a four-second loop. Watch where the feet land and which way the bicycle seems to travel.

GPT-6.2 Astra · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Astra · A cycling pelican in motion capture
Checked facts
  • Both use a four-second native SMIL loop. At zero and four seconds, frames matched in the standalone HTML test and differed in the standardized capture.

GPT-6.2 Sol · MAX

Silent original-work capture.

Download MP4

Sol · A cycling pelican in motion capture
Checked facts
  • Both use a four-second native SMIL loop. At zero and four seconds, frames matched in the standalone HTML test and differed in the standardized capture.

AUTHOR COMMENTARY · My choice · GPT-6.2 Astra

Astra comes into its own here. The legs make more sense and the background is easier on the eyes. Sol’s bike looks as if it is moving backwards, and the overlap between the beak and the setting sun bothers me.

My overall take (excerpt)

I did not see a clear advantage for Astra. It only pulled ahead of Sol with its two points for the pelican. I would not call OpenAI’s GPT-6.2 launch a success. I have seen others online saying it fell short, and this hands-on test left me with much the same impression.

Test conditions and sources

Separate Codex author sessions ran gpt-6.2-astra and gpt-6.2-sol. Runtime records confirmed MAX for both. Each pair shared its task, source images and capture protocol. First submissions were frozen.

Handheld images are the original renders. The web and SVG captures come from the first submissions. Answer cards visualize the original JSON. Interactive previews bundle local dependencies. ZIP files retain the original files and checksums.

Per-task wall times include tools, self-checks and rendering. The sessions expose cumulative usage only, so per-task token counts and costs are unavailable.

Per-task records and artifact hashes · Bilingual article data